Show 54 Results

Used Subaru Models in Butler, PA

Make:Subaru

EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Slate Black
Used 2018
Subaru Legacy 2.5i

Stock # 25BT05067A

Mileage 55,922

Body Style Sedan

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 34 | CITY 25

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Vehicle Use

Service History

Market Value $18,900

Diehl Discount - $929

Diehl Price $17,971

Diehl Price $17,971

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl of Butler

(724) 608-3340
EXTERIOR

Geyser Blue

INTERIOR

Gray
Used 2024
Subaru Outback Wilderness

Stock # 25MR0692A

Mileage 5,153

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 26 | CITY 21

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $36,744

Diehl Discount - $1,244

Diehl Price $35,500

Diehl Price $35,500

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl of Moon

(412) 239-8900
EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Slate Black W/Silver
Used 2024
Subaru Ascent Touring

Stock # WS2175A

Mileage 11,009

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 25 | CITY 19

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $45,999

Diehl Discount - $1,999

Diehl Price $44,000

Diehl Price $44,000

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Crystal Black Silica

INTERIOR

Warm Ivory
Used 2022
Subaru Outback Limited

Stock # WH2870M

Mileage 19,906

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $31,528

Diehl Discount - $632

Diehl Price $30,896

Diehl Price $30,896

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Honda of Massillon

(330) 639-2479
EXTERIOR

Crystal White Pearl

INTERIOR

Gray
Used 2024
Subaru Forester Sport

Stock # 25SF2160A

Mileage 16,361

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $33,214

Diehl Discount - $3,288

Diehl Price $29,926

Diehl Price $29,926

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl of Sharon

(724) 608-3682
EXTERIOR

Crystal White Pearl

INTERIOR

Java Brown
Used 2018
Subaru Outback 3.6R

Stock # WK2449B

Mileage 102,996

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 27 | CITY 20

Vehicle History

Accident Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $21,200

Diehl Discount - $2,167

Diehl Price $19,033

Diehl Price $19,033

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Kia of Massillon

(330) 639-2479
EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2022
Subaru Forester Premium

Stock # WSPT0025

Mileage 33,680

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $29,500

Diehl Discount - $900

Diehl Price $28,600

Diehl Price $28,600

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Cascade Green Silica

INTERIOR

Gray
Used 2022
Subaru Forester Premium

Stock # WS1971A

Mileage 31,233

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $29,250

Diehl Discount - $1,250

Diehl Price $28,000

Diehl Price $28,000

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Crystal Black Silica

INTERIOR

Slate Black
Used 2023
Subaru Outback Limited

Stock # WS2314A

Mileage 15,340

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 32 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $32,998

Diehl Discount - $2,393

Diehl Price $30,605

Diehl Price $30,605

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Crystal Black Silica

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2022
Subaru Forester Premium

Stock # WSP0396

Mileage 36,922

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $30,258

Diehl Discount - $3,258

Diehl Price $27,000

Diehl Price $27,000

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Crystal White Pearl

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2021
Subaru Forester Premium

Stock # WDY0302A

Mileage 79,282

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

2-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $23,925

Diehl Discount - $3,025

Diehl Price $20,900

Diehl Price $20,900

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Hyundai Mitsubishi of Massillon

(330) 639-2479
EXTERIOR

Horizon Blue Pearl

INTERIOR

Black W/Orange Stitching
Used 2022
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Stock # WS2332A

Mileage 18,737

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 28

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $28,188

Diehl Discount - $3,124

Diehl Price $25,064

Diehl Price $25,064

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Crystal White Pearl

INTERIOR

Black W/Orange Stitching
Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Stock # WS2026A

Mileage 13,626

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 28

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $29,999

Diehl Discount - $2,999

Diehl Price $27,000

Diehl Price $27,000

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Magnetite Gray Metallic

INTERIOR

Black W/Orange Stitching
Used 2022
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Stock # WDS0383B

Mileage 19,127

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 28

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $28,118

Diehl Discount - $2,218

Diehl Price $25,900

Diehl Price $25,900

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Cool-Gray Khaki

INTERIOR

Black W/Orange Stitching
Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Stock # WDS0375A

Mileage 34,492

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 28

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $27,995

Diehl Discount - $2,495

Diehl Price $25,500

Diehl Price $25,500

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Sapphire Blue Pearl

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2024
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Stock # WH2635B

Mileage 17,337

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 34 | CITY 27

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $28,599

Diehl Discount - $2,299

Diehl Price $26,300

Diehl Price $26,300

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Honda of Massillon

(330) 639-2479
EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2024
Subaru Impreza 2.5RS

Stock # WS1479

Mileage 2,904

Body Style Hatchback

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Vehicle Use

Service History

Market Value $29,125

Diehl Discount - $2,825

Diehl Price $26,300

Diehl Price $26,300

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2024
Subaru Impreza 2.5RS

Stock # WS2311A

Mileage 22,435

Body Style Hatchback

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 33 | CITY 26

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $28,150

Diehl Discount - $2,378

Diehl Price $25,772

Diehl Price $25,772

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Cool-Gray Khaki

INTERIOR

Gray w/Yellow Stitching
Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Stock # WDS0381A

Mileage 27,388

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 34 | CITY 27

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $30,255

Diehl Discount - $2,415

Diehl Price $27,840

Diehl Price $27,840

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Plasma Yellow Pearl

INTERIOR

Gray w/Yellow Stitching
Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Stock # WS2319A

Mileage 12,729

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 34 | CITY 27

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Diehl Price $27,500

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Slate Black
Used 2019
Subaru Legacy 3.6R

Stock # WS2296B

Mileage 69,118

Body Style Sedan

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 28 | CITY 20

Vehicle History

Accident/Minor Damage

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $22,876

Diehl Discount - $2,720

Diehl Price $20,156

Diehl Price $20,156

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Crystal White Pearl

INTERIOR

Slate Black
Used 2019
Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium

Stock # WHP0581A

Mileage 78,245

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 32 | CITY 25

Vehicle History

Minor Damage

3+ Owners

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $18,515

Diehl Discount - $1,015

Diehl Price $17,500

Diehl Price $17,500

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Honda of Massillon

(330) 639-2479
EXTERIOR

Ice Silver Metallic

INTERIOR

Black
Used 2020
Subaru Impreza Premium

Stock # WSPT0014B

Mileage 29,987

Body Style Hatchback

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 36 | CITY 28

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Personal Use

Service History

Market Value $21,950

Diehl Discount - $3,950

Diehl Price $18,000

Diehl Price $18,000

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241
EXTERIOR

Sapphire Blue Pearl

INTERIOR

Gray
Used 2025
Subaru Crosstrek Base

Stock # WS2049

Mileage 5,137

Body Style SUV

Drivetrain AWD

HWY 34 | CITY 27

Vehicle History

No Accident or Damage Reported

CARFAX 1-Owner

Vehicle Use

Service History

Market Value $28,300

Diehl Discount - $2,100

Diehl Price $26,200

Diehl Price $26,200

Confirm Availability Estimate Payments Value Your Trade
Diehl Subaru of Massillon

(330) 578-4241

Disclaimer

Diehl Automotive utilizes a system that generates market value pricing automatically for new and pre-owned vehicles and may cause errors, inaccuracies, or omissions. Some aftermarket additions or accessories may not be displayed properly. For accuracy, please contact the dealer for real-time, accurate pricing. A documentation fee of $477 applies and is not included in the pricing. Tax, Title, and Tags are also not included and must be paid by the purchaser. Some prices may include manufacturer-to-dealer offers that are not compatible with manufacturer special finance programs and/or lease offers. While great effort is made to ensure the accuracy of the information on this site, errors do occur so please verify information with a customer service rep. This is easily done by calling us at (724) 608-3428 or by visiting us at the dealership.

Toyota Dealer in Butler, PA

Search our large inventory of quality used vehicles for your next car, truck, SUV, sedan, crossover, or electric vehicle. Great prices on popular Toyota models like the Camry, RAV4, Corolla, Avalon, Prius, 4Runner, Tacoma, Tundra, Sequoia, C-HR, and more. All used Toyotas pass our rigorous inspection and detailing process. Vehicle history reports provide peace of mind. Schedule a test drive. Car financing and protection plans available. The team at Diehl Toyota Butler is ready to help you find the perfect used Toyota today!

Monday	9 AM - 8 PM
Tuesday	9 AM - 8 PM
Wednesday	9 AM - 6 PM
Thursday	9 AM - 8 PM
Friday	9 AM - 6 PM
Saturday	9 AM - 4 PM
Sunday	Closed

Monday	7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday	7:30 AM - 6 PM
Wednesday	7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday	7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday	7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday	8 AM - 1 PM
Sunday	Closed

Monday	8 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday	8 AM - 6 PM
Wednesday	8 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday	8 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday	8 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday	8 AM - 1 PM
Sunday	Closed

Order a vehicle online

from Diehl Toyota

Year

Type

Vehicle History

Make

Model

Trim

Year

Price Range

Mile Range

Body

Cab Style

Bed Style

Fuel

Range

Transmission

Color

Drivetrain

Location

MPG Highway

MPG City

Features

Used Subaru Models in Butler, PA

Used 2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i

Used 2024 Subaru Outback Wilderness

Used 2024 Subaru Ascent Touring

Used 2022 Subaru Outback Limited

Used 2024 Subaru Forester Sport

Used 2018 Subaru Outback 3.6R

Used 2022 Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2022 Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2023 Subaru Outback Limited

Used 2022 Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2021 Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2022 Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2022 Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2024 Subaru Impreza 2.5RS

Used 2024 Subaru Impreza 2.5RS

Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Used 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Used 2019 Subaru Legacy 3.6R

Used 2019 Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium

Used 2020 Subaru Impreza Premium

Used 2025 Subaru Crosstrek Base

Disclaimer

Toyota Dealer in Butler, PA

Don't see the vehicle you are looking for? Complete the form below and we will find it for you!

Contact Info

What Are You Looking For?

Payment Calculator

Dealer Alchemist

Used 2018
Subaru Legacy 2.5i

Used 2024
Subaru Outback Wilderness

Used 2024
Subaru Ascent Touring

Used 2022
Subaru Outback Limited

Used 2024
Subaru Forester Sport

Used 2018
Subaru Outback 3.6R

Used 2022
Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2022
Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2023
Subaru Outback Limited

Used 2022
Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2021
Subaru Forester Premium

Used 2022
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2022
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2024
Subaru Crosstrek Premium

Used 2024
Subaru Impreza 2.5RS

Used 2024
Subaru Impreza 2.5RS

Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Used 2023
Subaru Crosstrek Sport

Used 2019
Subaru Legacy 3.6R

Used 2019
Subaru Outback 2.5i Premium

Used 2020
Subaru Impreza Premium

Used 2025
Subaru Crosstrek Base